Source: KJV Issues, row 2

Critique this analysis ↗
Textual

Deut 8:9 — KJV renders Hebrew nechosheth as 'brass' ('out of whose hills thou mayest dig brass'), while NRSVUE and NIV render it 'copper', implying the KJV made a metallurgical/translation error.

Refutation

Concede the point honestly, but locate it correctly: this is a documented shift in English word-sense, not an error in reading the Hebrew. נְחֹשֶׁת (nechosheth) denotes copper or copper-based alloys generically. In 1611 English, 'brass' was used loosely for copper and copper alloys alike (compare the KJV's 'brazen serpent' and 'brazen altar', both referring to bronze/copper objects) — a broader semantic range than the modern, narrower sense of 'brass' as a copper-zinc alloy. This is a known instance of lexical semantic narrowing in the history of English, not evidence the KJV translators misunderstood the underlying Hebrew geology. Archaeological work at sites such as Timna and Faynan has since confirmed Iron Age copper mining exactly in the region Deuteronomy describes, which is precisely the kind of comparative and archaeological data 1611 translators lacked. Modern translations correct the English gloss using improved metallurgical and archaeological knowledge — a routine act of lexicography, not a discovery that the underlying Hebrew text is unstable.

Positive case

The underlying Hebrew consonantal text (נְחֹשֶׁת) is stable across the manuscript tradition; only the English gloss changed as archaeological knowledge of ANE metallurgy (e.g., the Timna and Faynan copper-mining complexes) improved. Self-correction in translation vocabulary, without any change to the source text, is evidence of translational and textual integrity working as intended.

Steelmanned objection

Describing a metal as literally dug/mined out of hills while calling it 'brass' is metallurgically confused, since brass is a manufactured copper-zinc alloy, not a native ore — suggesting the KJV translators' technical vocabulary (and by extension their broader accuracy) cannot be trusted.

Fallacy tags

none tagged

Sources cited

  • Walter Kaiser, The Old Testament Documents / OT background studies — on ANE metallurgy and Hebrew technical vocabulary
  • John Currid, Ancient Egypt and the Old Testament — on ANE comparative context for OT material culture

Scripture referenced

Deut 8:9

Confidence

concedes-difficulty-but-not-fatal

Review status

no content-completeness issues flagged

Source locator

KJV Issues → row 2 locator: low confidence

Related arguments

1 of 10 in KJV Issues