failed-prophecies-006

Needs manual review — bare reference/URL with no stated argument; no refutation was invented for this row.

Raw entry: 'Matthew misattributes John as the Messenger in Malachi 3' — title only, with link to Matt 11:10 and Malachi 3:1-4 (NRSVUE); no supporting quote or commentary stated.

Related arguments

'Matthew 22:41-45 vs. Psalm 110 (Jesus doesnt understand Psalm 110)' — title only, with link to Psalm 110 and Matt 22:41-45 (NRSVUE); no supporting quote or commentary stated.Prophetic Failed Biblical Prophecies & ot
Row 19 of the source spreadsheet is entirely blank (no title, quote, commentary, or link) — no content to evaluate.Prophetic Failed Biblical Prophecies & ot
'Genesis 3 15' — bare scripture citation with a link to Genesis 3 (NRSVUE), no argument or commentary stated.Prophetic Failed Biblical Prophecies & ot
'Hebrews 8 "turned away from them" vs Jeremiah 31' — bare scripture citation with link to Heb 8:7-9 and Jer 31:32 (NRSVUE), no argument or commentary stated.Prophetic Failed Biblical Prophecies & ot
'Luke makes up a prophecy.' — bare scripture citation to Luke 24:45-47 (NRSVUE), no argument or commentary stated.Prophetic Failed Biblical Prophecies & ot
Matthew 2:14-15 says Joseph fled with Jesus to Egypt 'to fulfill what had been spoken by the Lord through the prophet, "Out of Egypt I have called my son."' The quoted line is Hosea 11:1, which in its own context is plainly retrospective — God describing what he already did in bringing Israel (the nation, collectively, as 'my son') out of Egypt at the Exodus, immediately followed by verses about Israel's subsequent unfaithfulness and coming judgment (return to exile). It is not framed as a prediction about any future individual, let alone a messiah, and Matthew's citation as fulfilled prophecy is either a misunderstanding or a deliberate misuse of the text.Prophetic Failed Biblical Prophecies & ot